About 10 years before that incident, a 4-year-old named Kalākaua [5] witnessed the lynching of his grandfather, Chief Kamanawa II. Raedeen Keahiolalo-Karasuda shares in "A Genealogy of Punishment in Hawaii: The Public Hanging of Chief Kamanawa II” that,
The forcing of 800 natives at gunpoint to witness the chief’s lynching was said to serve as an "object lesson to evil-doers". Tragically, two witnesses among the crowd were the chief’s grandsons, 8-year-old James Kapa'akea and 4-year-old Kalākaua, both of whom were brought by their missionary teachers to watch the execution (148).
Fast forward to 1932 and an American named Grace Fortescue [6], in reference to the lynching of Joseph Kahahawai said "You know, I originally come from the South and where I come from, we have a way of dealing with niggers and that's what this was all about” (The Massie Affair).
You see, long before special agent Christopher Deedy shot Kollin Elderts (Daranciang), long before the Stanford Prison Experiment (Zimbardo), and before na waimaka o ka lani, or the “tears of heaven” fell upon mourners [7] at Joseph Kahahawai's funeral (Stannard 262), Hawai'i knew that America was racist with a deep (his)tory of punishment and imprisonment.
Now, here we are in 2020. The…Best…Year...Ever and the ‘eha (pain) and kaumaha (heaviness, sorrow) of George Floyd's death is universally felt. They say there might be a vaccine for COVID-19 in a year or so, but will there ever be a vaccine for racism and its infectious nature?
I used to question if a nation that was founded on the massacre of Native Americans [8] and the backs of Black slaves could evolve beyond what Harvard Professor Henry Louis Gates Jr. calls "America's Cultural DNA" (Thomas). I used to wonder if America could progress past this “race thing,” that in some ways is foreign to Pacific Islanders who understood their identity through cosmogonic genealogy. Still, at the age of 243 years old and in respect to ancient and living Indigenous Peoples; America is still a young country.
Color blindness is not the answer and neither is violence. Our issues, lives, and the complexities of race, ethnicity, justice, equality and equity become entangled in Chi-raqs, police brutality, and the classic “crabs in a barrel” complex in a C.R.E.A.M. world (Wu-Tang Clan). The game of hate is one we play with ourselves and each other and it is a vicious cycle that can only be broken through aloha (reciprocated love and respect), education, and community work.
Me ke aloha a mau pule no ka 'ohana o George Floyd,
Bubzy
Click link, learn more, and donate!
The Pōpolo Project
https://www.thepopoloproject.org/
Black Trans Travel Fund
https://www.blacktranstravelfund.com/
The Innocence Project
https://www.innocenceproject.org/
End Notes: Hawaiian language words are not italicized in this text as a normalizing process for understanding words and ideas through different portals of understanding and because they are not foreign to the author. English translations are offered within each text and subsequent to all Hawaiian language terms and ideas.
1 Image courtesy of the Library of Congress. In 1897 the satirical magazine Puck printed this political cartoon depicting “another shotgun wedding, with neither party willing” between Uncle Sam and a female personification of Hawaii. President William McKinley officiates the wedding while Senator John Tyler Morgan of Alabama, who supported American expansion, stands watch.
2 After the American learned from the hotel manager that Prince Kūhiō was an ali'i, the American said "I didn't know your highness. I got all I deserved. Will you honor me by joining me for a drink?" but there is no record of Prince Kuhio accepting his invitation (Soboleski).
3 ‘Prince Jonah Kalaniana‘ole, better known here as “Cupid” is well recognized as man who likes to eat but prefers to fight. “Cupid” is making a tour of the world, and the popular young Hawaiian is having plenty to eat and also plenty to fight.’ ‘The young Hawaiian ali‘i is very sensitive in regard to his complexion, and to call him a “colored” person means a scrap, as the records of the Police Court here will show. While on his trip around the world with his charming wife, there are so far two fights to his credit, and his purse is lighter by a fine of $500’ (Pacific Commercial Advertiser).
4 Starting in 1849, Kamehameha IV ventured on a world tour to Europe, Washington D.C., New York, California, Panama, and Jamaica. Fluent in both French and English, Alexander was well received in European society. <http://www.ulukau.org/elib/cgi-bin/library?e=d-0ks10-000Sec--11en-50-20-frameset-book--1-010escapewin&a=d&d=D0.6&toc=0>
5 David Laʻamea Kamananakapu Mahinulani Naloiaehuokalani Lumialani Kalākaua was the last reigning king of the Kingdom of Hawai‘i. “One year after Kalākaua was enrolled at the boarding school, the Cookes took him to the gallows to witness the hanging of his grandfather. In her diary, Juliette Cooke noted that “a man” who was to be hanged had summoned Kalākaua to the old fort (Allen, 1994), but it is quite curious as to why she and her husband kept the 4-year-old at the gallows to witness the execution of his grandfather. Allen surmised that the Cookes’s decision was likely based on a disregard for Kaläkaua’s genealogical standing in relation to the Kamehameha legacy. However, according to documented excerpts from the Cookes’s journals, it is probable that their disdain for Hawaiians influenced their decision as well (see Richards, 1941). What’s more, historical records indicate that Chief Kamanawa II had asked to see his grandsons and not for his grandsons to see him be put to death. The execution left an indelible impression on the minds of Kalakaua, who never forgot the traumatic incident, and Lili’uokalani, who shared in the pain of knowing about her grandfather’s capital execution” (Karasuda 154).
6 Grace Fortescue was the mother of Thalia Massie. “In the fall of 1931, Thalia Massie, the bored, aristocratic wife of a young naval officer stationed in Honolulu, accused six nonwhite islanders of gang rape. The ensuing trial let loose a storm of racial and sexual hysteria, but the case against the suspects was scant and the trial ended in a hung jury. Outraged, Thalia’s socialite mother arranged the kidnapping and murder of one of the suspects. In the spectacularly publicized trial that followed, Clarence Darrow came to Hawai’i to defend Thalia’s mother, a sorry epitaph to a noble career” (Penguin Random House).<https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/291248/honor-killing-by-david-e-stannard/”
7 After the casket was lowered into the ground and the mourners were leaving the cemetery it began to rain lightly. Hawaiians call this na waimaka o ka lani – the “tears of heaven” – a sign that the gods are weeping in sympathy. Though little more than a mist, it was foretaste of things to come in the weeks ahead. After a year of uncommon dryness in the islands, for day after day throughout the next month the skies opened in a deluge that caused rivers and streams to turn a deep red with runoff from the hillsides. It is called uakoko in Hawaiian, “blood rain” (Stannard 262).
8 German leader, Adolf Hitler, modeled his treatment of Jewish people after the American policies implemented against Native Americans - specifically the Bosque Redondo concentration camp where thousands of Navajo men, women, and children were sent after the Long Walk in 1864 (Indian Country Today).
Sources:
"Ali'i Sunday - Commemoration of King Kamehameha IV." The Cathedral of St. Andrew. 8 February 2016. https://www.thecathedralofstandrew.org/alii-sunday-commemoration-of-king-kamehameha-iv/>
“Cupid as a Pugilist: Hawaiian Prince In Two Lively Scraps.” The Pacific Commercial Advertiser. 13 April 1901. Lib. of Cong.<https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn85047084/1901-04-13/ed-1/seq-1/><https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn85047084/1901-04-13/ed-1/seq-4/>
Daranciang, Nelson. “Christopher Deedy cannot be retried for manslaughter in Waikiki shooting, federal appeals court say.” Star Advertiser. 7 November 2019.
Foerster, Brien. The Real History of Hawaii: From Origins to the End of the Monarchy. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, 2013.
“Hitler Studied U.S. Treatment of Indians.” Indian Country Today. 8 August 2016.<https://indiancountrytoday.com/archive/hitler-studied-u-s-treatment-of-indians-pYDkk-692Ei3XkztuwKVhg>
Keahiolalo-Karasuda, RaeDeen. “A Genealogy of Punishment in Hawai‘i: The Public Hanging of Chief Kamanawa II.” Hulili: Multidisciplinary Research on Hawaiian Well-Being, Vol. 6, 2010.<http://kamehamehapublishing.org/_assets/publishing/hulili/Hulili_Vol6_7.pdf>
“The Massie Affair.” American Experience, directed by Mark Zwonitzer, PBS, 2005.
Soboleski, Hank. "Prince Kuhio defends his honor". The Garden Island. 4 October 2015.<https://www.thegardenisland.com/2015/10/04/lifestyles/prince-kuhio-defends-his-honor/>
Stannard, David. Honor Killing: Race, Rape, and Clarence Darrow’s Spectacular Last Case. Penguin Books, 2005.
Taylor, Charles Jay. “Another Shotgun Wedding, with Neither Party Willing.” Cartoon. Puck. 1 December 1897, Volume 42: 1082.<https://history.house.gov/Exhibitions-and-Publications/APA/Historical-Essays/Exclusion-and-Empire/Hawaii/>
Thomas, Cal. "Act against racism, rioting - and toward redemption." Star Advertiser. 2 June 2020, A11.
Wu-Tang Clan. “C.R.E.A.M.” Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers), 1993.
Zimbardo, Philip G. “Stanford Prison Experiment”. Social Psychology Network, 1971.<https://www.prisonexp.org/>
Zimbardo, Philip G. The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil. Penguin Random House LLC., 2007.